Yoast vs All In One SEO (2025) — Which Plugin Is Better?

Confused between Yoast vs All In One SEO? At first the two plugins might look exactly the same, but there are some peculiar differences between the two.

For instance, Yoast SEO uses a traffic light keyword optimization system, whereas AIOSEO scores your content out of 100 in terms of keyword optimization.

That’s not all, and there’s a lot more to it. By the end of this guide, you will have a clear answer for which is the right plugin for you. Let’s get started!

Yoast vs. All In One SEO: An Overview 

Yoast SEO is best for those who like simplicity. For more granular control and extra features, AIOSEO can be the right option, along with its slight affordability compared to Yoast.

Details	Yoast SEO	All In One SEO (AIOSEO)
Pricing starts at	$99/year	$49.60/year
Free version	Yes	Yes
Key Features	Basic keyword analysis, readability check, single keyword optimization (free), advanced internal linking (premium)	Multi-keyword analysis, schema markup, redirection manager, local SEO, WooCommerce SEO
What it helps with	Helps optimize content for SEO with readability and keyword checks	Provides advanced SEO tools, automation, and flexible optimization settings
Best for	Users who want to key SEO optimization features and simplicity	Users who want better control over features
G2 ratings	4.6/5	4.7/5

How Did I Test Yoast SEO And AIOSEO?

I installed both plugins on separate WordPress sites(to avoid conflicts between them) to see how easy or complicated the setup process was.

Parameters I Tested

• Ease of Use: I checked how beginner-friendly each plugin is, from installation to daily usage.
• Price: I compared their free and premium versions to see which offers better value.
• Setup: I reviewed their onboarding process to see how quickly I could get started.
• Interface: I explored their dashboards to check the layout, navigation, and overall experience.
• Monitored site performance: I wanted to check whether either plugin slowed the website.
• Explored Features: I tested key features like content analysis, keyword optimization, schema markup, and redirections.

This hands-on approach gave me a clear idea of how Yoast SEO and AIOSEO perform in real-world scenarios so that I could write this comparison much better.

Understanding Yoast And AIOSEO Better

Let’s understand these tools in a much better way below:

Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO is one of the most popular WordPress SEO plugins, with over 10 million active installations. It was developed by Joost de Valk and launched in 2010. 

Yoast SEO is also the most downloaded SEO plugin, boasting over 5 million active installations.

Since its launch, Yoast SEO has evolved significantly, offering features such as real-time content analysis, schema.org integration, and customizable title and meta descriptions.

These tools help users to optimize their content effectively, aiming to improve search rankings and drive organic traffic.​

Pros:

• Simple interface, making it beginner-friendly.
• Helps optimize content with relevant keywords.
• Identifies long sentences and complex structures.
• Creates XML sitemaps for better crawling.
• Allows editing meta descriptions for better CTR.

Cons:

• This can lead to over-optimization.
• The free version lacks deeper SEO tools.
• It can slightly slow down websites with many features enabled.

AIOSEO

All in One SEO (AIOSEO) is another powerful SEO plugin for WordPress, with over 2 million active installations. 

It was created by Michael Torbert and launched in 2007. AIOSEO serves over 3 million users, providing features like TruSEO on-page analysis, keyword rank tracking, and content performance insights.

These tools empower users to optimize their content effectively, aiming to improve search rankings and drive organic traffic.

Pros:

• Easy to navigate for non-technical users.
• Covers meta tags, sitemaps, schema, and social media integration.
• Allows detailed SEO settings for each post/page.
• Includes internal linking suggestions and a redirect manager.
• Provides detailed documentation and customer assistance.

Cons:

• Some features may be overwhelming at first.
• Advanced tools require SEO knowledge to maximize benefits.
• Occasional compatibility issues and glitches with certain plugins.

By now, you have an idea of what both these tools bring to the table. But how reliable and true is it? Let’s understand each feature below:

Yoast Vs. AIOSEO: Feature Comparison

AIOSEO offers more features than Yoast; for example, AIOSEO offers WooCommerce SEO with its most basic plan. If you use Yoast, you have to purchase a separate plugin for it. 

Yoast aims to keep its plugin lightweight, and AIOSEO offers an all-in-one solution. Let’s compare some other features of the tools as well:

Features	Yoast	AIOSEO
Keyword optimization scores	✅	✅
Site search appearance customization	✅	✅
Readability optimization	✅	✅
Schema markup	✅	Only with Premium
Sitemaps	✅	✅
Headline Optimizer	❌	✅
Integration with webmaster tools	✅	✅
Inbuilt Woocommerce SEO support	❌	✅
Cornerstone content	✅	Only with Premium
Breadcrumbs	✅	✅
Link optimization	Internal link counter	Broken link checker (200 free link checks per month)
USP	All essential features are free	Headline & competition analysis + site audit

Comparing The Installation & Setup Of Yoast vs AISEO

Setting up an SEO plugin should be short, simple, and beginner-friendly. Yoast offers a more straightforward 5-step setup process, whereas AIOSEO has a 7-step process. Let’s see how both the tools compare in detail below.

Yoast SEO

Once installed, Yoast SEO requires you to head over to SEO > General and manually launch the configuration wizard, or the first-time configuration, as Yoast calls it. It’s a simple five-step process.

The wizard guides you through key settings step by step, making it easier for beginners to get started without feeling overwhelmed.

Yoast organizes its settings into multiple pages, each with distinct tabs. This structure keeps things well-arranged but may require some extra clicks to navigate. 

To assist users, an on-screen help button is available at the bottom of every page. Clicking it provides instant access to support documentation, making troubleshooting easier.

All In One SEO

All In One SEO takes a more streamlined approach. As soon as you activate the plugin, you can launch the setup wizard in the plugin’s dashboard. 

You can also watch the YouTube video, which is embedded right next to it, if you are entirely clueless about the process.

The wizard itself is simpler than Yoast’s and has 7 steps and sub-steps, which might overwhelm some if you have no prior SEO plugin setup knowledge. 

After completing the setup, the main settings panel is located under All in One SEO > General Settings. 

Unlike Yoast, each option comes with a help icon that provides short explanations, ensuring users understand what they’re adjusting. There’s also a dedicated help button for further assistance if needed.

Verdict: Both plugins are beginner-friendly, but All In One SEO simplifies the process even further. With its automatic setup wizard and built-in help options, it offers a smoother onboarding experience compared to Yoast.

Keyword Optimization: All In One SEO Vs. Yoast

Yoast offers a traffic light keyword optimization system, whereas AIOSEO leans towards a scoring system. It comes to personal preference about which one is better here, but beginners often prefer Yoast. 

Let’s see how Yoast and AIOSEO fare against each other when it comes to keyword optimization below.

Yoast

Yoast helps you optimize your content with Flesch reading ease score, keyword usage tips, and reminders, including alt text for images.

It uses a simple traffic light system—green (good), orange (needs improvement), and red (poor)—to show your SEO performance.

However, the free version supports only one keyword per post, whereas the premium version allows up to five.

All In One SEO (AIOSEO)

AIOSEO provides keyword suggestions and ensures you don’t forget to add them in key areas, including alt text.

Instead of a color-coded system, it assigns a 0-100 SEO score, offering a more detailed optimization overview.

Both free and premium versions support multiple keywords, but the premium version unlocks advanced optimization features and additional keyword phrases. 

Verdict: Yoast is best for those who like a simpler approach to SEO. AIOSEO scoring system is best for a clearer breakdown and precision.

Schema Support: Yoast Vs. All In One SEO

Both Yoast and AIOSEO offer schema support, but if you are looking for a comprehensive catalog then AIOSEO can be the right option for you. Plus, AIOSEO’s Next-gen schema generator makes it easy to add schema to the posts.

Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO automatically adds schema metadata to posts and pages. You can customize the schema type for individual posts and pages through the Yoast SEO meta box (It can be found below your article)

However, its schema catalog is limited. If you need a specific schema type that’s not included, you’ll have to use filters and hooks, which require some technical knowledge.

AIOSEO

AIOSEO, on the other hand, allows you to set custom schema types for different content types. 

Its Next-Gen Schema Generator, which was made live with version 4.2.5, makes it easy to add any schema type without writing code, although you can do that too!

There is also a Schema Catalog that offers a wider range of schema options, making customization more flexible.

Verdict: Both plugins offer schema support, but AIOSEO makes it more accessible with its Next-Gen Schema Generator and extensive Schema Catalog.

Ecommerce SEO Support: Yoast Vs. All In One SEO

Yoast SEO does not have built-in WooCommerce support, unlike AIOSEO. Plus, you have to pay extra for a separate Yoast WooCommerce SEO plugin on top of Yoast’s SEO plugin, which many find unappealing. Let’s look at the details.

Yoast SEO

Yoast supports WooCommerce, but for a full eCommerce schema, you need the Yoast WooCommerce SEO plugin, which costs extra!

It lets you add product titles and descriptions like regular posts and pages. Once installed, you can provide additional product data and generate a product category XML sitemap.

You also get access to Yoast’s e-commerce training course with this WooCommerce plugin.

All-in-One SEO

AIOSEO automatically applies the Product schema when you add a product—no extra setup is needed. 

It also lets you customize schema details, such as brand, colors, and product manufacturer. Like Yoast, it also generates XML sitemaps for products and categories automatically. 

If you’re not using WooCommerce but still want to optimize a page as a product, you can manually set its schema type in AIOSEO.

Verdict: All-in-One SEO wins with its built-in eCommerce schema support, which is available in its most basic plan. Unlike Yoast, it doesn’t require an extra plugin.

Pricing: Yoast Vs. All In One SEO

Yoast offers no special discounts but a solid 30-day moneyback guarantee. AIOSEO is currently offering a 60% discount on all its plans but only a 14-day money-back guarantee. Let’s take a look at some other details:

Yoast

Yoast SEO premium costs $99 per year. There is only one plan users can choose from. However, users can opt for the package deals if you have multiple websites.

Yoast also offers a 30-day money-back guarantee if the user is unsatisfied with its products. 

With the premium plan, you get year-long access to all SEO and AI features, 24/7 support, and all the Yoast SEO Academy courses!

But there’s a way with which you can save on your Yoast subscription! Yoast SEO Premium offers bulk discounts starting at 5 subscriptions, with up to 30% savings for 40+ subscriptions. 

For 50+ subscriptions, users can contact Yoast for a custom deal. No discount code is required.

AIOSEO

AIOSEO offers an option to choose from four plans, which is helpful for beginners. Let’s take a look at them below:

• Basic: $49.60/year
• Plus: $49.60/year
• Pro: $49.60/year
• Elite: $49.60/year

AIOSEO also offers a 14-day no-risk money-back guarantee to its users who are unsatisfied with its offerings.

You also get 60% off across the board—$449.40 off Elite, $299.40 off Pro, $149.40 off Plus, and $74.40 off Basic. This is one parameter that sets AIOSEO apart from Yoast, which currently has no active discounts.

Verdict: AIOSEO offers a cheaper starting point and more features than Yoast SEO. Affordability-wise, AIOSEO is the clear winner here.

AIOSEO vs Yoast: Real User Reviews

Sometimes, the best way to learn how a plugin works is by reading real user reviews, which often paint a real picture. I have compiled some for you below:

A G2 user, Akhtar, appreciates the ease of use of Yoast and talks about how he also likes its on-page SEO settings:

One Reddit user, r/BarryAllen_mdr, was not impressed by how Yoast slowed down his website. Read the entire review below:

Coming to AIOSEO, a G2 user, William rated AIOSEO 5/5 and highlighted that he likes everything from the features, interface, and automation capabilities. Read the entire review below:

Another G2 user, Oskari, didn’t have a similar experience, though, as she found AIOSEO to be buggy and left a strong review on the G2 platform. Read the review below:

Customer Support And Resources: AIOSEO Vs Yoast

Be it any plugin, customer support and resources are crucial. Let’s look at how Yoast and AIOSEO fare against each other under this parameter.

Yoast

Yoast does not offer dedicated customer support for free users. If you run into issues, you’ll have to rely on the public forum to find answers from other users.

Premium users, however, get priority support, which means faster responses and direct help from the Yoast team.

One area where Yoast stands out is its learning resources. It has a well-maintained blog, Yoast SEO Academy, with courses, webinars, and detailed documentation for developers. 

If you would like to dig deeper into SEO, Yoast provides plenty of material from which to learn.

All In One SEO

Like Yoast, All In One SEO offers forum support for free users, so you won’t get direct assistance unless you upgrade to the premium version.

One advantage of the premium version is its focus on eCommerce SEO, making it a solid choice for WooCommerce users who need advanced SEO support.

While AIOSEO also has a technical blog and documentation, it isn’t as detailed as what Yoast offers. For basic troubleshooting, it’s sufficient, but it doesn’t go as deep into SEO education.

Verdict: Support-wise, both platforms are the same; however, Yoast offers extensive learning resources, making it a better choice for those who want to build their SEO knowledge while using the plugin.

AIOSEO vs Yoast: Room For Improvement

After assessing the plugins, I have identified a few areas where both plugins can improve. Starting with Yoast:

Yoast SEO

Yoast is a great SEO plugin for beginners, however, its higher costs can also drive them away from using the plugin. Plus, features like WooCommerce SEO should not require a separate plugin.

1. Premium Features and Cost: 

While the free version offers basic functionalities, advanced features like internal linking suggestions and a redirect manager require the premium version, which starts at $99 per year. 

This higher cost might not appeal to budget-conscious users, especially beginners who are just starting.

2. Complex Setup Process: 

Yoast’s setup wizard includes 12 steps, offering extensive customization but potentially overwhelming beginners.

3. Performance Impact: 

Some users like Efficient_Pen3804 from Reddit have reported that Yoast SEO can slow down their websites, particularly on larger sites with extensive content.

This could be a major hurdle and make people look for Yoast alternatives since Google loves web pages that load faster. It’s one of the essential ranking factors.

All in One SEO (AIOSEO)

AIOSEO can have a slight learning curve for beginners. It has plenty of features, but users sometimes do complain about minor bugs and glitches that negatively affect the user experience.

1. User Interface: While functional, some users feel that AIOSEO’s interface is less intuitive compared to competitors, potentially leading to a steeper learning curve. It’s a 50-50 where some like it, and some just don’t.

2. Feature Overload: AIOSEO offers a comprehensive set of features, which can be overwhelming for users who only require basic SEO functionalities. Its Headling Analyzer took me some time to get used to, despite prior knowledge.

While the plugin provides sufficient help, I think it could benefit from more educational content like Yoast usually puts out.

3. Support Limitations: Some users have noted that AIOSEO’s support can be slow, which may be challenging for those needing immediate assistance. A live chat feature might also be a good feature to have.

Verdict: Yoast SEO could enhance user experience by simplifying its setup process and addressing performance concerns, while AIOSEO might benefit from priming its customer support and addressing common glitches.

Related Reads:

• Rank Math vs Yoast SEO
• Best WordPress SEO Plugins

Conclusion: Yoast Can Be Your Perfect SEO Plugin Choice

After extensive hands-on testing, I would use Yoast for my projects. But, the choice between Yoast SEO and AIOSEO comes down to your specific needs. 

Yoast excels with its intuitive traffic-light system and comprehensive educational resources, making it ideal for beginners who value simplicity and guided optimization. 

Meanwhile, AIOSEO offers superior value with more features at a lower price point ($49.60/year vs. $99/year), built-in WooCommerce support, and granular control that experienced users will appreciate. 

While Yoast keeps things streamlined, AIOSEO provides an all-in-one solution with advanced customization options. 

Ultimately, choose Yoast for simplicity and learning or AIOSEO for feature-rich flexibility and better pricing—both will effectively boost your site’s search visibility.

FAQs